Greater educational freedom a silver lining to the shutdowns: John Stossel
The government has closed most schools.
So, more parents are teaching kids at home.
That upsets the government school monopoly.
Education “experts” say parents lack the expertise to teach their kids.
Without state schooling, “learning losses… could well be catastrophic,” says The New York Times. Home schooling “will set back a generation of children,” according to a Washington Post column. Harvard Magazine’s “Risks of Homeschooling” article quotes a professor who calls for a “presumptive ban.”
The professional education establishment actually tried to ban it 98 years ago. Then, they tried to ban private schools, too! But the Supreme Court stopped them, writing, “a child is not the mere creature of the state.”
I wish the state would remember that.
Anyway, the educator’s complaints about home schooling “setting back a generation” are bunk.
Eleven of 14 peer-reviewed studies found home schooling has positive effects on achievement.
Education researcher Corey DeAngelis explains, “Children who are home-schooled get much better academic and social results than kids in government schools.”
Even though they are more likely to be poor, “Home-schoolers score 30% higher on SAT tests.” They also do better in college, and they are less likely to drink or do drugs.
“Mass home schooling during this pandemic,” says DeAngelis, “may actually be a blessing.”
Debbie Dabin, a mom in Utah, is one of many parents who started home schooling this spring and now is “definitely considering home schooling” next year.
Dabin bought teaching materials over the internet from a company called “The Good and the Beautiful.” Her son likes the lessons better than what he got in school. “It’s great,” Dabin says. “He likes the activities; he wants to do them.”
Before the pandemic, he’d told his mom he hated school.
I hated school, too. Classes were boring. Listening to lectures is a poor way to learn, and unnecessary today.
In addition to home-school teaching programs, there are also free internet games that teach things like math, reading and writing, while customizing the speed of lessons to each learner’s needs.
Sites like Education.com teach math by letting kids adjust pizza toppings.
For older kids, YouTube channels like TED-Ed and Khan Academy offer “free educational videos from the world’s foremost experts on civics, history, mathematics,” adds DeAngelis.
“Not good enough!” say “experts.”
Michael Rebell, a professor at Teachers College at Columbia University, worries that if parents home-school, “There’s no guarantee that kids are learning democratic values, civic knowledge.”
“Were they learning that in their regular schools?” I asked.
“Well… it’s in the curriculum,” he responded.
So what? The Nation’s Report Card, the government’s biggest nationwide test, reveals that government-school students don’t know much about history or civics.
One question asked fourth graders, “Which country was the leading communist nation during the Cold War?” Only 21% answered the Soviet Union. More said France or Germany. American students did worse than if they had guessed randomly.
Another question: “America fought Hitler and Germany in which war?” More picked the Civil War than World War II.
Nevertheless, said Rebell, home schooling is still worse because “there’s no effective regulation to know what’s going on.”
“You sound like you think — because there’s regulation, that makes something happen,” I said.
“I do,” he replied. “Where there’s no regulation, that’s a worse situation.”But “no regulation” is the wrong way to think about it. There is plenty of regulation. It just comes from legislators and families instead of education bureaucrats.
If this pandemic steers more parents away from state schools, that’s probably a good thing.
Philosopher John Stuart Mill warned: “State education is a mere contrivance for moulding people to be exactly like one another… which pleases the predominant power in the government (and) establishes a despotism over the mind.”
A silver lining to this pandemic is that now more parents are learning about their options outside the government system.
John Stossel is author of “Give Me a Break: How I Exposed Hucksters, Cheats, and Scam Artists and Became the Scourge of the Liberal Media.”